Magic/Big O is a really tough call. I would personally put Magic above because of the number of championships he won and he revolutionized the game by proving a big man can play guard.
Oscar had dominating stats but he just didnt have the postseason success until the last couple years of his career.
"Big O"? theres a reason for that name. did you read my post above? Oscar Robertson was the pioneer NOT magic. and the league was not set up the way it is now with free agents and these things its not O's fault he was stuck on the cincinatti royals for ten years.