What you are really saying is there is no way a kid from a D3, D4 or D5 school should ever be considered. That's just wrong.
I won't disagree with Davis should he win but you can't ignore what JO has done in his senior year when the award is for seniors. BTW I am not sure his coach doesn't play his own kid way too much instead of letting JO stay in games.
I'm not saying anyone below D2 shouldn't ever win the award. I'm literally comparing the two players based off what has been accomplished during their senior seasons. I'm personally more impressed with what Johnny Davis has done this season. It's my opinion, you may feel different.